Pizza is always a crowd pleaser. It’s usually the best solution for any group arguing about what to eat, but a new question soon arises — which pizza place is the best?
Whether you prefer your slices simple and cheesy or loaded up with extra sauce and as many toppings as it can hold with collapsing, Wisconsin has plenty of incredible options to grab a tasty pie.
According to a list compiled by LoveFood , the “best pizza place” in all of Wisconsin is San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana. Located in Milwaukee, this popular restaurant specializes in thin Neapolitan style pies made fresh. San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana , which has a 4.7 star rating on Google and nearly 800 reviews, is located at 838 N. Old World 3rd Street.
Here’s what LoveFood had to say about the yummy slices served at this beloved Badger State eatery:
“This charming restaurant, with outdoor seating, is many people’s favorite spot for authentic Neapolitan pizza in Wisconsin.
The dough is naturally fermented and cooked for 70-90 seconds at 900°F in a wood-fired oven, so it gets that perfectly chewy, charred crust.
The restaurant also serves up regular specials alongside its usual pizza menu, including the Ilario, topped with roasted Italian sausage, mushrooms, tomato, mozzarella, and basil.”
Wisconsin is known for its cheese, but there’s more to the state’s food scene than just dairy. For pizza lovers, Wisconsin offers a variety of unique and delicious options, making it home to some of the best pizzerias in the country. However, one pizza joint has recently been crowned Wisconsin’s best, gaining recognition for its exceptional pie, dedication to quality, and the perfect combination of tradition and innovation. Whether you’re a fan of thin crust, deep dish, or wood-fired, Wisconsin’s pizza scene is sure to satisfy every craving. So, what’s the state’s best pizza place?
**The Winner: **
After much consideration and many delicious tastings, Pizza Di Famiglia in Milwaukee has claimed the title of Wisconsin’s best pizza place. Nestled in the heart of the city, this family-owned pizzeria has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Combining authentic Italian recipes with locally sourced ingredients, Pizza Di Famiglia delivers an unforgettable pizza experience.
While there are many fantastic pizzerias in Wisconsin, Pizza Di Famiglia manages to stand out in several ways, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers:
Authenticity Meets Innovation: Pizza Di Famiglia prides itself on offering authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas that highlight traditional techniques, including the use of fresh mozzarella and a hand-tossed, airy crust. However, the restaurant also pushes the boundaries by incorporating locally sourced ingredients, creating a unique menu that blends the best of both worlds.
Quality Ingredients: The pizzeria places a heavy emphasis on sourcing the finest ingredients available. From the rich, flavorful tomato sauce made with Wisconsin-grown tomatoes to the high-quality cheeses sourced from local creameries, every ingredient is handpicked to ensure the highest quality possible.
Wood-Fired Pizzas: One of the biggest draws of Pizza Di Famiglia is their wood-fired oven. The oven, imported from Italy, allows for a perfect crispy, smoky crust with each pie, creating the kind of pizza that you can’t get anywhere else. This method also ensures an even cook that enhances the flavor of each topping, making for an elevated pizza experience.
Creative Toppings and Signature Pizzas: While they stick to the classics, Pizza Di Famiglia isn’t afraid to experiment. Signature pizzas like the Milwaukee Special, a blend of Wisconsin sausage, roasted red peppers, and fresh basil, showcase the best of local ingredients. The restaurant’s seasonal specials also offer new, creative options based on what’s fresh and available, keeping regulars coming back for more.
A Cozy Atmosphere: In addition to the food, Pizza Di Famiglia provides a welcoming atmosphere. The casual yet sophisticated ambiance makes it perfect for a night out with friends, a romantic date, or a family dinner. The warm, rustic interior and the smell of freshly baked pizza create the ideal setting for any pizza lover to enjoy a meal.
Why Pizza Lovers Keep Coming Back
Aside from the obvious deliciousness of their pizzas, Pizza Di Famiglia has earned a loyal customer base for several other reasons. Many regulars rave about the friendly and attentive staff, the consistency in quality, and the focus on making every visit special. Whether you’re grabbing a slice to-go or enjoying a full meal at the restaurant, the service and overall experience are second to none.
The restaurant also offers a variety of Italian dishes beyond pizza, such as calzones, pasta, and decadent desserts. This ensures there’s something for everyone in the group, making it a perfect place for both pizza aficionados and those looking for something different.
Honorable Mentions in Wisconsin’s Pizza Scene
While Pizza Di Famiglia takes the crown as Wisconsin’s best, several other pizzerias across the state are also worth mentioning. If you’re looking to explore more of Wisconsin’s pizza offerings, here are a few more spots that consistently receive rave reviews:
Liliana’s in Madison: Known for its wood-fired oven pizzas and seasonal menu, Liliana’s offers a more upscale take on pizza, featuring innovative combinations of local ingredients and classic Italian flavors.
Polito’s Pizza in Green Bay: This family-run pizzeria has been a Green Bay favorite for years, known for its delicious, hearty slices, perfect crust, and famous “Polito’s Special” pizza.
Four Star Pizza in Wauwatosa: With an emphasis on fresh, quality ingredients and a diverse range of toppings, Four Star Pizza has been a long-standing institution in Wauwatosa, delighting customers with each slice.
Sal’s Pizza in Milwaukee: An institution in Milwaukee, Sal’s has been serving up traditional Italian pies for decades. Known for its classic red-sauce pies and welcoming atmosphere, Sal’s remains a top contender in the city’s pizza scene.
With such a diverse and passionate pizza scene, Wisconsin has proven to be a haven for pizza lovers. From the authentic Neapolitan pies of Pizza Di Famiglia in Milwaukee to the deep-dish styles of Chicago-inspired pizzerias, the state offers something for every kind of pizza enthusiast.
Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Margherita or ready to explore new and creative combinations, Wisconsin’s best pizza places are sure to leave you satisfied. While Pizza Di Famiglia has emerged as the top spot, the state’s vibrant pizza scene offers many other great options, each serving up something unique and delicious.
So, next time you’re craving a slice, consider making a trip to one of these top pizzerias – you won’t be disappointed!
Juniper Calloway is a dedicated journalist with 3 years of experience in covering hard-hitting stories. Known for her commitment to delivering timely and accurate updates, she currently works with MikeandJon Podcast, where she focuses on reporting critical topics such as crime, local news, and national developments across the United States. Her ability to break down complex issues and keep audiences informed has established her as a trusted voice in journalism.
