The girlfriend of the man accused of murdering Sayreville councilwoman Eunice Dwumfour has now come forward with critical information that could reshape the ongoing investigation. According to new details revealed during police questioning, the woman has identified the murder weapon and claims it was linked directly to her boyfriend—the man charged in the killing.
The case, which had already stirred emotions across New Jersey due to its political implications, took another dramatic turn when the girlfriend told investigators that the handgun found at the scene looked like the one her boyfriend had shown her in the past. Her statement adds a major piece to the puzzle in a case where evidence has been closely examined, and motives have remained unclear.
Authorities say that the councilwoman was gunned down near her car in February 2023. The scene was violent and chaotic, with shell casings found nearby and few initial leads. Investigators later arrested Rashid Ali Bynum, a man with connections to Dwumfour through church affiliations and shared professional interests. But until now, direct links to the weapon used had remained largely speculative.
Now, according to court documents and police interviews, Bynum’s girlfriend allegedly recognized the gun and stated that she had seen him carrying it before the incident. She further claimed that he had made troubling remarks around the time of the murder—words that, in hindsight, now raise serious red flags. Her full testimony has not been made public, but law enforcement sources say her cooperation has strengthened the case against Bynum.
Investigators had already recovered a weapon they believed was used in the crime, but matching that gun definitively to the suspect had proven challenging. This new testimony may serve as a much-needed link tying the suspect to the scene. Officials familiar with the investigation say that forensic testing is still underway, including fingerprint and ballistic analysis.
What’s even more unsettling is the motive investigators are now beginning to piece together. While nothing has been confirmed, sources suggest a mix of personal and ideological tensions might have been involved. Dwumfour, known for her deep religious beliefs and involvement in church activities, had ties to the same faith group as Bynum, though it’s unclear if that connection turned sour.
The girlfriend reportedly came forward after noticing inconsistencies in her boyfriend’s behavior. According to people close to her, she struggled for weeks before speaking to investigators. When she finally did, she shared texts, conversations, and past experiences that pointed to possible involvement in the councilwoman’s death.
This new development could heavily influence how the case proceeds in court. Prosecutors are expected to lean on her testimony to show not only possession of the weapon but also intent. Defense attorneys, however, are likely to question the timing and credibility of her statement, arguing that it may be influenced by pressure or fear.
The local community in Sayreville has followed this case closely, given Dwumfour’s role as a trailblazing figure. She was one of the few Black councilwomen in the town’s history and had made significant strides during her time in office. Her sudden and violent death shocked residents, many of whom described her as a warm, dedicated public servant.

While no official motive has been released, and the investigation is still ongoing, authorities now feel they are closing in on a clearer picture of what happened. The girlfriend’s claims are expected to play a central role in upcoming hearings, and prosecutors are preparing to introduce both her statement and the physical evidence during the trial.
Public reaction has been mixed. Some view the new information as a breakthrough, while others caution that the case must still be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. Legal experts say the reliability of a witness who was close to the suspect will be heavily scrutinized, and it’s possible the defense will try to cast doubt on her memory, motives, or mental state.
Despite the questions, officials say they are confident in the direction of the case. The combination of witness testimony, forensic testing, and phone records could provide the complete chain of evidence needed to move forward.
The case has also drawn attention from beyond Sayreville, with state and even national media outlets watching closely. Political killings are rare in the U.S., and when they do happen, they send shockwaves through communities. That’s exactly what happened here, and the fallout is still being felt across the state.
As the legal process unfolds, the role of the girlfriend may become one of the most critical pieces in the trial. Her decision to come forward, possibly at great personal risk, could help bring justice to a case that has haunted a town and left a family grieving. Authorities are urging anyone else with information to step forward, reminding the public that solving crimes like this often requires community cooperation.

Jon King is an experienced journalist with 3 years of experience in the field. With a strong background in investigative reporting, Jon is known for his in-depth coverage of crime news, finance news, local news, and USA news. Currently working with Mikeandjonpodcast, Jon brings his sharp investigative skills, where he provides timely updates and analysis on a wide range of topics. His commitment to delivering accurate and impactful news has earned him a reputation for providing insightful and comprehensive stories that resonate with his audience.