Coca-Cola’s holiday ads have long been a staple of Christmas cheer, synonymous with nostalgia, the joy of family gatherings, and the festive spirit. However, this year, the beverage giant’s 2024 Christmas commercial is sparking controversy—and not in the way they might have expected. Instead of filling viewers with holiday warmth, many are describing the ad as “genuinely so terrifying.”
The commercial, which premiered earlier this month, features a surreal, almost dream-like sequence that blends the traditional holiday imagery Coca-Cola is known for with unsettling, eerie visuals. As expected, the ad shows scenes of holiday merriment—families, snowy landscapes, and decorated homes—but it also introduces a rather unnerving twist that has left audiences divided.
The Ad’s Concept: Surrealism Meets Holiday Cheer
In the commercial, the familiar red Coca-Cola truck is seen driving through a snowy, seemingly picturesque town. However, as the ad progresses, the upbeat holiday music gives way to a disconcerting, almost dystopian feel. In one of the more unsettling scenes, animated polar bears—longtime mascots of Coca-Cola’s festive ads—are shown in bizarre, uncanny positions. Their eyes appear too wide, and their movements are too stiff, creating an eerie vibe rather than the usual heartwarming charm the brand is known for.
The ad is also filled with moments that challenge the traditional imagery of Christmas. From overly exaggerated lighting effects that seem to distort reality to the appearance of distorted reflections in windows, Coca-Cola’s attempt to add a magical layer to its usual advertising has caused some to feel uncomfortable rather than enchanted.
Viewer Reactions: ‘Genuinely So Terrifying’
While some have praised the commercial for its boldness and creativity, many viewers are expressing their discomfort with the eerie visuals and unsettling tone. Social media has been flooded with reactions, with numerous viewers describing the ad as “genuinely so terrifying.”
“Why does the polar bear look like it’s about to eat me?” one viewer tweeted. “This is giving me nightmares, not Christmas cheer.”
Another viewer remarked, “The music sounds joyful, but the visuals make it feel like something is about to go wrong. It’s not Christmas. It’s horror.”
In fact, some viewers have likened the ad to a “holiday horror movie” or even compared it to a “Twilight Zone” episode, where the familiar becomes strange, creating an uncanny and unsettling effect. For many, it’s a far cry from the cozy, warm-hearted ads Coca-Cola is famous for.
Coca-Cola’s Attempt at Bold Innovation
Is Christmas Vacation! 3 new school holidays announced for New York State Districts?
Coca-Cola aimed to break away from its traditional holiday marketing by infusing a sense of surrealism and artistic ambition into its 2024 campaign. The company may have hoped to stand out among the sea of familiar holiday commercials that tend to follow the same nostalgic formula.
In recent years, Coca-Cola has leaned into creative and experimental ads, particularly with their holiday campaigns. This year’s effort is perhaps an attempt to take their marketing into new, uncharted territory—an innovative direction that evokes a certain level of mystery and curiosity.
However, it seems that the brand may have miscalculated the balance between innovation and the comfort viewers expect during the festive season.
What’s Next for Coca-Cola’s Holiday Campaign?
Given the backlash, it’s unclear how Coca-Cola will respond. Historically, the brand is known for listening to its audience and quickly adjusting to public sentiment. In fact, their advertisements in the past have evolved based on feedback and cultural shifts, and the 2024 holiday commercial could undergo modifications in future airings.
For now, however, it seems that Coca-Cola’s attempt to shake up the holiday commercial landscape has left some fans scratching their heads rather than reaching for a bottle of Coke. The disturbing imagery in what is meant to be a feel-good season is something many viewers are struggling to reconcile with the spirit of Christmas.
Conclusion: A Risky Move?
While the 2024 Coca-Cola holiday ad might be one of the brand’s most ambitious to date, it’s also one of its most divisive. Coca-Cola’s usual holiday campaigns are synonymous with heartwarming nostalgia and happy moments, yet this year’s ad challenges that tradition in ways that some viewers are finding uncomfortable, even terrifying.
The question now is whether this bold experiment will pay off or if Coca-Cola will reconsider its approach to holiday advertising. One thing is clear: The 2024 holiday ad will be remembered, but not for the reasons Coca-Cola might have hoped.
