Claiming Social Security at 62 and Investing—Does It Really Pay Off?

Many Americans face a tough decision when it comes to Social Security—should they claim benefits as early as age 62 or wait until full retirement age (FRA) or even 70 to receive larger monthly payments? One alternative strategy that some retirees consider is claiming Social Security early and investing the money. But does this really pay off in the long run? Let’s break it down.

How Social Security Benefits Change Over Time

The age at which you start collecting Social Security has a direct impact on how much you receive each month. Here’s how it works:

• At Age 62, you can claim Social Security at the earliest age, but your monthly benefit will be permanently reduced compared to waiting longer.
• At Full Retirement Age (FRA) (66-67): If you wait until your FRA, you receive 100% of your calculated benefits.
• At Age 70: Delaying benefits until age 70 results in the highest possible monthly payout, with an increase of about 8% per year after FRA.

By taking benefits early, you lock in lower payments for life, but you also get access to cash sooner. If you choose to invest those funds instead, could you come out ahead financially?

The Investment Strategy: Taking Social Security Early and Investing It

Some financial experts argue that if you take Social Security at 62 and invest it wisely, you could potentially grow your savings beyond what you would have received by waiting for larger monthly checks. However, this strategy depends on several factors, including market conditions, investment returns, and life expectancy.

Scenario Analysis: Comparing Different Approaches

Let’s assume two people, John and Mary, each have a Social Security benefit of $2,000 per month at full retirement age (67). Here’s what happens based on their choices:

• John claims at 62: His benefit is reduced by about 30%, so he receives $1,400 per month instead of $2,000. However, he invests this amount in the stock market with an average 7% annual return.
• Mary waits until 67: She doesn’t claim benefits until full retirement age, receiving $2,000 per month for life.

Over time, John builds up investment gains, while Mary receives higher guaranteed payments. If John lives to 85 and earns steady market returns, he may end up with more total wealth than Mary. However, if the stock market underperforms or he lives much longer, Mary’s guaranteed income could be more beneficial.

The Risks of Claiming Early and Investing

While investing in early Social Security payments can be appealing, there are risks:

1. Market Volatility: The stock market can be unpredictable. A downturn in the market could wipe out gains and leave you with less than expected.
2. Longevity Risk: If you live longer than expected, you may run out of money if your investments don’t perform well.
3. Loss of Guaranteed Income Growth: Social Security payments increase over time if you delay claiming, and they are adjusted for inflation. Investments don’t always guarantee the same long-term security.
4. Tax Implications: Depending on your other income sources, Social Security benefits may be taxed, and investment income could create additional tax liabilities.

Who Might Benefit from This Strategy?

Claiming Social Security early and investing might work best for:

• People with shorter life expectancy: If you don’t expect to live into your late 80s or 90s, taking benefits early and investing could be beneficial.
• Confident investors: If you have experience managing investments and are comfortable with market risks, this strategy may offer higher returns.
• People with other income sources: If you don’t rely on Social Security as your main income source, investing in early benefits could help grow your wealth.

Who Should Consider Waiting?

Waiting to claim Social Security is often a better choice for:

• Those who expect to live longer: If you have a family history of longevity, delaying benefits ensures you get higher guaranteed payments for life.
• Risk-averse individuals: If you prefer a steady, reliable income, waiting until FRA or 70 provides higher monthly payments.
• People without substantial savings: If Social Security will be your main source of retirement income, maximizing your benefits is usually the safest choice.

Final Thoughts

Claiming Social Security early and investing the money can work for some people, but it’s not a guaranteed success. Market risks, longevity, and personal financial needs all play a role in whether this strategy will pay off.

Before making a decision, it’s best to consult a financial advisor and carefully evaluate your own situation. The right choice depends on your investment experience, expected lifespan, and financial goals. While taking benefits early offers immediate cash flow, waiting often provides greater long-term security.

Understanding these factors is crucial to making an informed decision. Whether you choose to claim early and invest or wait for higher benefits, planning ahead will ensure a more stable and comfortable retirement.

Source

---

Disclaimer: This article has been meticulously fact-checked by our team to ensure accuracy and uphold transparency. We strive to deliver trustworthy and dependable content to our readers.