In the final weeks before his exit as Missouri House Speaker, Dean Plocher’s tenure was rocked by a series of controversies, ranging from last-minute hiring attempts to unresolved ethics investigations. His successor, Jon Patterson, wasted no time in undoing some of Plocher’s decisions and implementing reforms aimed at restoring credibility to the House.
Last-Minute Hiring Attempts & Power Struggles
Before officially stepping down in January, Plocher’s office attempted to push through legislative hires despite Jon Patterson being named the incoming speaker. On December 17, Patterson sent an email to Plocher, accusing his chief of staff, Hampton Williams, of bypassing the incoming House leadership to make personnel decisions. Patterson requested an urgent conversation, and ultimately, the hires never took place.
Ethics Investigations & Unpaid Legal Fees
Plocher’s time as Speaker had been plagued by allegations of ethical misconduct, including improper reimbursement claims and pressure on nonpartisan staff. To investigate these claims, the House had hired an outside attorney. However, Plocher’s office refused to authorize payment for the attorney’s work, leaving an outstanding bill of $14,000. Patterson settled the issue soon after taking office, approving the overdue payment.
Failed Attempt to Change Ethics Rules
In a controversial move, Plocher’s office attempted to convene a hearing in November to alter House ethics policies. If successful, the changes would have limited investigations into legislative expense accounts—the same issue that had put Plocher under scrutiny. Despite efforts to secure attendance from Democratic lawmakers, the meeting failed to reach a quorum and was ultimately cancelled.
New Ethics Rules & Legislative Reforms
After Plocher’s departure, Patterson moved quickly to implement reforms addressing the weaknesses exposed by his predecessor’s ethics scandals. The House passed new rules requiring a Speaker to recuse themselves from ethics investigations if they are the subject of a complaint. Additionally, the changes clarified that the Ethics Committee can hire outside legal counsel without the Speaker’s approval.
The ‘Butler’s Pantry’ Controversy
One of the more bizarre aspects of Plocher’s tenure was his decision to convert Room 306B in the Missouri Capitol into a storage room stocked with liquor, beer, wine, and soda. Dubbed the “Butler’s Pantry,” the room was originally designed as an office space for legislative staff.
Once media attention grew, the liquor was removed, and the space was temporarily repurposed for interns. Patterson promptly restored Room 306B as an office, assigning it to State Representative Bishop Davidson, a key figure in budget committee leadership.
Ongoing Lawsuits & Political Fallout
Even after leaving office, Plocher’s actions continue to have legal repercussions. The Missouri House is facing two separate lawsuits from legislative employees who claim they experienced retaliation and threats from Plocher. One of these cases was dismissed in December but is expected to be appealed, while the second lawsuit was filed in early February.
A Fresh Start for Missouri’s House Leadership
With Plocher out and Patterson taking the reins, Missouri’s House leadership is focused on cleaning up lingering controversies and reinforcing ethical standards. While Plocher denies any wrongdoing, his tenure as Speaker left behind a trail of political turmoil, legal battles, and credibility concerns.
As Patterson implements new policies and restores order, the Missouri House is hoping to move forward from a period marked by controversy and ethical dilemmas.
Disclaimer: This article has been meticulously fact-checked by our team to ensure accuracy and uphold transparency. We strive to deliver trustworthy and dependable content to our readers.
Benjamin Ford is a dedicated local journalist passionate about reporting on community news, events, politics, crime, and finance. With a sharp eye for detail and a commitment to uncovering impactful stories, he provides in-depth analysis and timely updates on issues that matter to the local audience. Benjamin enjoys engaging with the community and staying informed on emerging trends when he’s not covering the latest developments.