Social Security in Crisis: How Immigration and Declining Migration Rates Are Affecting Benefits?

Social Security is a cornerstone for millions of retired Americans. For many, the monthly check they receive is more than just extra income — it’s vital to maintaining a comfortable retirement life.

Since 2002, Gallup’s surveys have shown that between 80% and 90% of retirees depend on Social Security benefits.

A survey from April 2024 revealed that 88% of retirees rely on these benefits as a primary or secondary income source. Without Social Security, many would struggle to make ends meet.

Social Security’s Looming Crisis: Benefit Cuts on the Horizon

Social Security is facing a financial crisis that could lead to major cuts in benefits, possibly as soon as 2032.

The Social Security Board of Trustees releases an annual report that looks at the program’s income, expenses, and long-term financial health.

The most recent report, from 2024, warns that Social Security is dealing with a massive $23.2 trillion shortfall, and the program’s reserves could run out as early as 2033. This would force the government to make severe cuts to benefits.

While Social Security is not in danger of becoming bankrupt or failing to pay eligible beneficiaries, its long-term financial health is in jeopardy.

The system is funded primarily by a 12.4% payroll tax, but even with this, the program is not financially sustainable as it stands.

This is especially concerning for the nearly 70 million Americans who rely on Social Security each month.

Without immediate reforms, the program will face cuts to benefits of up to 21% in the next eight years.

This is an alarming projection that lawmakers cannot afford to ignore. The main factors contributing to this issue are low birth rates, rising income inequality, and crucially, immigration patterns.

Immigration and Social Security: An Ongoing Issue

For the past 25 years, discussions about Social Security’s financial issues have often focused on immigration.

Social media platforms, in particular, are full of posts that blame immigration, especially undocumented workers, for the program’s troubles.

However, this perspective is misleading and fails to acknowledge the role that legal immigrants play in sustaining Social Security.

The main source of income for Social Security is the payroll tax paid by workers. This includes taxes paid by legal immigrants.

Most legal immigrants to the U.S. are young and work for many years, contributing to the program before ever receiving benefits themselves. These workers are a major asset to the system, as they help to balance out the financial burden of an aging population.

According to projections by the Social Security Trustees, net migration into the U.S. needs to average 1.24 million people per year until 2098 to help reduce the program’s financial shortfall.

However, the rate of immigration into the U.S. has been falling. Between 1998 and 2023, net migration dropped by 58%. This decline in immigration is a key factor in Social Security’s worsening financial outlook.

Why Fewer Immigrants Are Coming to the U.S.

The issue isn’t that too many immigrants are coming to the U.S. — it’s that too few are arriving. Data shows that fewer people are migrating to the U.S. than in past decades, and this has serious implications for Social Security.

In 2024, the U.S. saw approximately 958,700 new immigrants, falling short of the necessary 1.24 million immigrants needed each year to maintain the program’s financial balance.

This decline in legal immigration has left a gap in Social Security’s funding model, making it harder to support the growing population of retirees.

The U.S. economy needs young workers to help fund benefits for older citizens, and immigration is a crucial way to achieve this.

Without more legal immigrants entering the workforce, Social Security will struggle to maintain its current payout structure.

Undocumented Immigrants and Social Security: The Misconception

While legal immigration is critical to the program, there is a common misconception that undocumented workers are a burden on Social Security.

In reality, undocumented workers contribute significantly to the program’s finances. Although these workers are not eligible for Social Security benefits, they still pay into the system through payroll taxes.

A 2014 study by New American Economy found that undocumented workers contributed around $100 billion to Social Security over the previous decade.

Confusion often arises because people mix up traditional Social Security benefits with Supplemental Security Income (SSI).

SSI is a separate program funded by the General Fund and is available to certain low-income individuals, including some asylum seekers.

However, undocumented workers are not eligible for traditional Social Security benefits, and they cannot access SSI either, except in rare cases.

Despite this, undocumented workers contribute around 1% of Social Security’s annual income, which helps support the program’s financial health.

Far from draining the system, undocumented workers are helping to keep it afloat. The real issue for Social Security is the decline in legal immigration, not the presence of undocumented workers.

The Need for Immediate Action

Social Security’s financial troubles will only worsen if lawmakers do not address the decline in legal immigration.

As the U.S. population ages, there are fewer workers paying into the system, and the number of retirees is increasing. Without more legal immigrants joining the workforce, the program’s financial stability is at risk.

To solve this issue, Congress must take action to increase immigration levels, particularly for skilled workers who can contribute to the U.S. economy and Social Security.

This would help ensure that the program remains solvent and continues to provide benefits for future generations.

Social Security is too important to be left to falter. The time to act is now before it’s too late to fix the issue.

By tackling immigration and addressing the broader financial challenges, lawmakers can help secure the future of Social Security for all Americans.

Note- Every piece of content is rigorously reviewed by our team of experienced writers and editors to ensure its accuracy. Our writers use credible sources and adhere to strict fact-checking protocols to verify all claims and data before publication. If any error is identified we promptly correct it and strive for transparency in all updates.